A featured contribution from Leadership Perspectives, a curated forum for business leaders, nominated by our subscribers and vetted by the Business Management Review Editorial Board.

OWNDAYS CO LTD

Henry Seals, Global Head of HR

High Performance Is Defined by What Happens When People Struggle

Henry Seals

Henry Seals

I have worked in large, established multinational companies and in startups, and my approach to building high-performing teams has not changed very much. I have come to believe that building a high-performing team is actually something of an exact science. The components are remarkably consistent wherever I go. You need clarity, trust, capable managers, meaningful work, accountability and an environment where talented people can develop and perform. The less scientific part is figuring out how to create all of those things among actual human beings, who unfortunately refuse to behave in predictable ways.

It starts with leadership and management savvy. There needs to be transparency and congruency around the company’s vision, mission, values and policies. In simpler terms, does the company actually do what it says it does? Employees figure out remarkably quickly when it does not. Then you need managers who can engage their teams, listen, delegate, recognize and manage the talent they have.

That last part is important because managing people is not simply encouraging them when things are going well. Eventually every manager encounters someone who is struggling, and this is where a great deal of leadership theory is tested.

Build a combination of ambition, accountability, trust and humanity, and people are much more willing to give you their best. And that, more than whether you have 50 employees or 50,000, is what creates a high-performing team.

What happens when an employee realizes the work simply is not for them? What about someone dealing with serious personal or emotional challenges affecting their performance? Or someone with long-held beliefs about work, themselves or the organization that prevent them from changing and adapting as the business changes?

A manager needs empathy, but empathy is not simply understanding how someone feels. It is understanding their situation well enough to determine what might actually help them. Sometimes that is coaching, development, patience or giving someone room to recover. Sometimes you have to let them fall and fail, experiencing the consequences of their choices. These lead to long, uncomfortable conversations about performance and, in the most difficult cases, helping someone leave the organization.

This is one of the most important parts of building a high-performing team. Not because removing a low performer magically turns everyone else into a high performer, but because everyone is watching how you do it. How you treat people when things are going badly sends a far more powerful message about your culture than how you treat people when everything is going well. If an employee is struggling and the organization humiliates them, suddenly changes the rules, treats them disrespectfully or seems determined to make their life miserable until they resign, the remaining employees notice. Even if they completely agree that the person was not performing, somewhere in the back of their minds a different question appears: what happens to me if I struggle someday?

That question matters because high performance requires a certain amount of risk. I want talented people to stretch themselves, take on difficult assignments, try things they have never done before and occasionally fail. It is difficult to create that environment if employees believe one bad period will suddenly make them disposable. This is why fairness and humanity in difficult situations are not simply nice things for an organization to demonstrate. They are part of the infrastructure of a high-performing team. You can hold people to very high standards while still treating them with dignity. In fact, I would argue that the higher your standards are, the more important that becomes.

And for the people who do leave, I try to remember that careers are long. Someone who feels slighted today may, after a few laps around other companies, eventually recognize that they were treated fairly by us compared to other companies. This helps with branding because employees can be customers and you want them to feel positive about the organization and endorse your products to others. Treating people with respect is just good business. 

So whether I am working in an established company or a startup, the ingredients remain largely the same. People need transparency about where the company is going and what is expected of them. They need to understand why their work matters and how their performance contributes to something larger than themselves. They need managers capable of recognizing talent, developing it, engaging it and holding it accountable. But they also need to know what happens when things do not go according to plan.

I think that last part is one of the foundations of resilience. High-performing teams are not teams where everyone performs perfectly all of the time. Those teams do not exist, despite what some performance reviews might have you believe. Resilient teams are ones where people can stretch, stumble, learn and recover, while understanding that standards still matter. Build a combination of ambition, accountability, trust and humanity, and people are much more willing to give you their best. And that, more than whether you have 50 employees or 50,000, is what creates a high-performing team.

The articles from these contributors are based on their personal expertise and viewpoints, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of their employers or affiliated organizations.