
Henry Seals
There are times as an HR leader when you know the long-term solution to a problem, and there is just one small inconvenience: you do not have the time to implement it. Perhaps you need better performance management, stronger talent development or greater transparency to improve employee engagement and motivation. Those may all be the right answers, but they could take months or even years to fully embed into an organization. Meanwhile, one department is losing employees at an alarming rate, performance is deteriorating and the manager needs help now. Or the company has launched an important new initiative and, despite an enthusiastic start it has stalled. Many times, what eventually happens is that someone turns to HR and asks us to intervene.
There are plenty of interventions available to us. We can coach the manager, facilitate a team session, improve communication, conduct listening sessions, clarify expectations or bring people together. The difference between the success and failure of an intervention is not the quality of the intervention itself, but whether you understood the context in which you are using it. One action from HR is unlikely to transform an organization if employees already have a negative perception of HR. Coaching a struggling manager will not work if the team has already stopped trusting that manager (employees may interpret every new behavior as temporary or insincere).
So for me, when it comes to HR interventions, it is context, context, context. Without a deep understanding of what is actually happening, even the most sophisticated intervention is ultimately a best guess. Before deciding what to do, I want to understand what happened before we arrived, how employees currently feel, whom they trust, what has already been tried and what they believe the organization is trying to accomplish.
Before deciding what to do, I want to understand what happened before we arrived, how employees currently feel, whom they trust, what has already been tried and what they believe the organization is trying to accomplish.
If engagement is high and employees generally trust leadership, an HR intervention connected clearly to the company’s mission, vision and values can be enormously powerful. Employees see that the organization is listening and responding, while leadership builds even more credibility. Everybody wins, and HR gets to look clever, which is always nice.
The challenge is what to do when that trust does not exist. In those environments, I believe HR needs to resist the temptation to continually jump from intervention to intervention hoping that something will work. Instead, we need to go back to the beginning and build a roadmap. What are the people and business outcomes we are trying to improve? What needs to happen first? What comes next? How will employees benefit? How will managers benefit? What should improve for the company and how will we measure whether any of this is actually happening? Individual interventions can then sit inside that larger story. Even when an emergency requires us to do something immediately, employees and managers can understand how that action connects to where the organization is trying to go.
This is also where continuous improvement becomes important. An HR roadmap should not simply be a collection of activities and completion dates. It should contain milestones and measurable outcomes. If we said we were going to improve management capability, what has actually changed? If we wanted to reduce attrition, did people stay? If we wanted to improve engagement, what happened to engagement? If the numbers are not moving, we need to be willing to admit that our wonderful intervention may not have been quite as wonderful as we thought and adjust accordingly. Every measurable improvement also gives HR something extremely valuable: credibility. People begin to trust interventions because they have seen previous ones produce results.
So I have become much less interested in asking which HR intervention is best and much more interested in asking what problem we are trying to solve, what has already happened and what people are ready to hear from us. Coaching, communication and continuous improvement are all powerful tools, but none operates independently of the environment around it. Build context through a clear roadmap, build trust by delivering measurable results and understand the business and cultural reality of the teams you are trying to help. Then, when the inevitable emergency arrives and someone asks HR to fix something immediately, you are no longer starting from zero. You have something far more useful than another intervention. You have credibility.


